Type to search


The Depraved Behind-the-Scenes Drama of the Unique Charmed: The Feuds, Firings and Feminist Fury


Life on the set of the unique Charmed? Something however charming lots of the time.

On Sunday, The CW is ready to introduce the story of three witchy sisters to a complete new technology, updating the Energy of Three for 2018 by casting three Latina ladies, making one of many sisters a lesbian and clearly establishing that “tearing down the patriarchy” was simply as vital as vanquishing demons. 

Forward of the reboot’s buzzed-about premiere, we’re wanting again in any respect the behind-the-scenes drama that went down on Charmed, which ran for eight season from 1998-2006 on The WB—together with the epic decade-long feud between two of its greatest stars, actors being let go for no cause, and, after all, the resentment a number of the unique forged has for the brand new model.

Be careful, one thing depraved (and nostalgic) this fashion comes…

Again in 1998, when it was introduced that Shannen Doherty was picked as one of many leads of Charmed, TV followers within the know have been a bit stunned given her historical past with its prolific producer Aaron Spelling

A fast refresh: Doherty was the feminine lead of slightly teen drama referred to as Beverly Hills, 90210, which Spelling created. From the present’s begin in 1990, Doherty, who was coming off of Heathers, had a little bit of a ‘tude and dangerous lady rep. 

“I am not saying I haven’t got my moments of bitchiness, as a result of all people has them, but it surely’s by no means for no cause,” she defined to Individuals in 1993. “I’ve at all times been a ballsy child. I do know it pisses some individuals off, however is not the tip end result a lot better?”

After years of on-set combating together with her fellow forged members (she and Jennie Garth allegedly got here to bodily blows) and the crew, Doherty was formally booted out of America’s most well-known zip code in season 4. (Author-producer Larry Mollin claimed that she angered the workers by chopping her hair midway via capturing the season finale, which was the ultimate straw.)

So yeah, the truth that Spelling was able to work with Doherty once more was considerably stunning. However Charmed creator Connie M. Burge informed InTouch that the uber-producer was “extraordinarily supportive of the concept of casting Shannen Doherty as Prue.” So that they had their eldest Halliwell sister, who had telekinetic powers.

Additionally working in Doherty’s favor was her historical past and chemistry with Picket Fences star Holly Marie Combs. “She was additionally pricey mates with Shannen,” Burge stated, “so that they had terrific chemistry with one another.” The present had it is center sister Piper, who may freeze time.

For the third sister Phoebe (who had the reward of premonition), producers initially forged Lori Rom, who filmed the unique pilot and even attended occasions to advertise the present. However Burge stated her exit was as a result of “private causes.”

Enter stage-left: Alyssa Milano, who was a giant get for Charmed due to her Who’s the Boss and Melrose Place fame. 

After Milano took over the function, Burge stated the youngest Halliwell sis modified a bit, as a result of, “I believe that Alyssa positively introduced a…excuse me, sexiness to the half.” 

And when Charmed premiered in October 1998, it was a direct hit for The WB and its highest-rated debut ever, with the Energy of Three becoming a member of the struggling community’s line-up of robust younger ladies that included Buffy Summers, Felicity Porter and Joey Potter. 

Charmed is an ideal postfeminist girl-power present,” Milano informed EW of the response to the present. “Even impartial of their particular powers, these ladies are robust, however they’re nonetheless female and accessible.”

Govt producer Brad Kern credited the success of the present largely to the chemistry of the starring trio in an E! particular, saying, “I believe that we form of caught lightning in a bottle with the ladies and their chemistry. I prefer to assume that we maintained it with good tales and good scripts and good manufacturing. But it surely begins out with the ladies.”

In the identical particular, Milano gushed, “I really feel that we’re extremely fortunate that the three of us discovered one another. All of us have horses so all of us have issues which can be in widespread. Holly and I maintain our horses on the identical ranch so we go driving on a regular basis collectively and we’re very comparable and, um, very shut, we’re blessed in that manner. It is like a giant slumber occasion daily. We giggle quite a bit.”

Doherty and Combs have been even bridesmaids at Milano’s 1999 marriage ceremony to musician Cinjuna Tate. (They divorced 10 months later.) 

However the spell seemingly had worn off by the start of season three, with experiences of main on-set pressure between Doherty and Milano, with no cause ever given for his or her falling out. A preferred principle is that Doherty was jealous of Milano’s rising reputation. One other is that Doherty was simply annoyed with the course the present was entering into and wasn’t shy about making her opinion recognized. (Burge reportedly left the present forward of season three when she turned annoyed that storylines have been extra targeted on the sisters’ relationships with their love pursuits than one another.)

Issues between the on-screen sisters obtained so dangerous that they reportedly solely spoke when completely needed. “There have been instances once I’d are available and say, ‘Good morning, Shannen,’ and she or he did not say something to me,” Milano admitted. “And there have been instances when she’d are available and say, ‘Good morning, Alyssa,’ and I would not say something to her.” 


The studio introduced in a mediator. It did not assist. The writing was on the decision, in line with one supply: “It will definitely turned clear that [either Doherty or Milano] needed to go.”

Whereas experiences recommended Milano supplied producers an ultimatum, the star denied doing so. Different experiences declare Doherty requested to be let go. 


And in Might 2001, it was introduced that Doherty was out after three years and 66 episodes on Charmed. Yep, it was déjà vu yet again for Spelling and Doherty.

“Now we have had an extended and affluent relationship with Shannen and we did not wish to maintain her again from what she wished to do,” Spelling Tv stated in an announcement. “We want her all the most effective and far continued success.”

As for Doherty, who had simply directed the season finale, she stated in an announcement: “I’ve actually loved my time with Charmed, specifically the devoted forged, crew and workers. I had the chance to create a personality, be taught and carry out my very own stunt work and direct three episodes of the present. Presently, I really feel that I’ve completed every little thing I got down to do once I returned to sequence tv.”

Whereas no point out of on-set pressure was in that assertion, Doherty spilled slightly little bit of tea when she sat down with Leisure Tonight for an unique interview about her hasty exit. 

“There was an excessive amount of drama on the set and never sufficient ardour for the work,” Doherty, who was arrested earlier that yr for a DUI, stated. “, I am 30 years outdated and I haven’t got time for drama in my life anymore.”

She did not precisely name Milano out, but it surely’s clear she was a lot nearer to Combs, who she alleged additionally wished out of the sequence.

Shannen Doherty, Alyssa Milano, Charmed, Tv Costar Feuds

The WB/Richard Cartwright

 “To me it is form of no matter. I will miss Holly quite a bit and that is actually the one factor I wish to clear up. She is considered one of my greatest mates and I like her dearly. And there have been by no means ever ever any issues between the 2 of us, and we are going to at all times be buddies,” Doherty stated. “And she or he does not even know if she’s going again to the present as a result of she does not wish to be there with out me.”

Combs stayed (after reportedly renegotitating her contract to make $60,000 per episode) and finally turned a producer in season 5, although she was publicly vocal about her ideas on how the producers dealt with Doherty’s exit, telling EW, “It was performed very poorly, for my part.”

Doherty wasn’t performed making pointed references to her feud with Milano, occurring to say, “I wish to work with actors who actually, actually care and that wish to be there each single day. I do not wish to work with individuals who b—ch about their job and complain about it and say that they hate it or the rest.”

So what was Milano’s facet of the story? 

In a 2001 interview with Leisure Weekly forward of the fourth season, Milano stated, “I believe it is arduous once you put…[long pause]…two very totally different individuals collectively. I am very laid-back and passive. I’ve my Buddha. I are available right here and meditate. [Shannen’s] obtained lots of power, she’s very headstrong, she desires to get the job performed.”

After Doherty’s interviews about her departure and feedback about Charmed being “a present for 12-year-olds,” Milano stated, “I believe it is unlucky that she left, and that she wanted to bad-mouth everybody concerned and the viewers. She sounds actually offended. I simply hope I did not contribute to that anger.”

Over a decade later, Milano form of reignited the feud when she was requested about Doherty’s firing on Watch What Occurs Stay! in 2013. 

“I do not know if she obtained fired, we by no means actually came upon what occurred,” Milano stated. “I can let you know that we have been on the air together with her for 3 years and there have been positively some tough days. Holly and Shannen have been greatest mates for like 10 years earlier than the present began so it was very a lot form of like highschool. I might hope that in our thirties it would not really feel like that anymore.” 

Combs was not down with Milano’s Imply Women evaluation, taking to Twitter.

Shannen Doherty, Holly Marie Combs

Stefanie Keenan/WireImage, Tibrina Hobson/Getty Photos

“Engaged on Charmed was nothing like highschool. I went to highschool. It was a vital job to me and at all times might be.” Doherty additionally chimed in: “Yeah, agreed, contemplating it helped me assist my household and pay for my dad’s medical points, however everybody has their opinion and views.” She did go on to defend Milano, saying WWHL may be “tough” and clarified there’s “no drama” occurring. 

And in 2015, BFFs Doherty and Combs did a be a part of interview on Sway’s Universe radio present, the place Combs addressed Milano’s highschool remark as soon as once more, saying, “She did not go to highschool! What are we speaking about right here? Her mom was at my marriage ceremony? Like, why? We have been all mates and at instances we weren’t.” 

Doherty added, “Had been there instances that have been tough? Yeah, once you work that carefully collectively there’s at all times going to be instances which can be tough.”

However by June 2017, it appeared just like the epic rift had reached its conclusion, as Milano informed E!’s Every day Pop hosts that she and Doherty had reconciled

“I believe we’re simply at ages now that what occurs 15 years in the past, or nonetheless way back that was, it is irrelevant,” Milano admitted.

In 2015, Doherty was recognized with breast most cancers, and Milano cited that as one of many driving forces behind their reunion. 

“I believe that what she has gone via, [and] motherhood in my life, I believe it simply adjustments individuals,” Milano stated. “I am so completely happy that she’s feeling effectively. I prayed for her daily that she would really feel effectively and I am unable to wait to see her.”

Marilyn Manson, Rose McGowan, MTV Video Music Awards

Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage.com

However again to 2001: With Doherty formally out, so started the seek for a brand new feminine result in play Paige, a half-sister who can transfer objects together with her thoughts. Producers actually wished Tiffani Amber-Thiessen, who paradoxically changed Doherty on 90210, to as soon as once more step in. Spelling informed Leisure Weekly, “Tiffani was our first option to take over for Shannen…Tiffani informed us she desires to do a half-hour comedy.” 

Their subsequent decide? Jennifer Love Hewitt, who additionally declined. 

Rose McGowan, recognized for her movie roles in Scream and Jawbreaker and engagement to rocker Marilyn Manson, was then forged as the brand new member of the family. 

“It labored out to our profit,” Kern informed TVLine of casting McGowan, “as a result of Rose introduced an entirely totally different character and a light-weight, goofy method—the alternative of what Shannen had dropped at the present. Rose’s quirky, approachable character shined via and gave us lots to work with.”

In her 2018 memoir Courageous, McGowan appeared again on the strain of becoming a member of an already established present.

“I wasn’t going to be enjoying Shannen’s function, but it surely was nonetheless somebody new for the followers to bond with. I had been informed that many present do not survive a serious forged change,” she wrote. “I knew that I had a slim likelihood at success right here. Individuals needed to fall in love with my character as rapidly as doable or Charmed would die. I thought of how massive the crew was and the way they might all be out of a job if I failed. So I made myself look tremendous nonthreatening. I gained weight, about ten kilos, for the function.”

She additionally wrote concerning the poisonous conduct on-set from the male crew members, calling her time on Charmed a “deadening expertise” and a “jail for [her] thoughts.”

Rose McGowan, Charmed

The WB/James White

Forward of her second season on the present, McGowan obtained in bother for dying her hair with out approval, and she or he determined to start hypnotherapy to cope with the stress.

“I discovered the repetitive days so reverse my pure rhythms that I turned sick time and again. And it was at instances a really hectic setting. I began to have panic assaults due to every little thing I used to be pushing down,” she wrote. “I used to be sick about 4 or 5 instances a season.” 

Nonetheless, she in the end wrote of the present, “For a very long time Charmed was—and would possibly nonetheless be —the longest-running female-driven hour-long present in historical past. I want we obtained extra credit score for that, as a result of it is vital.” (In 2012, Determined Housewives turned the longest-running female-driven present.)

After McGowan’s arrival, Charmed continued to be a rankings success for the WB, turning into its second highest rated present, and stayed on the air for 5 extra seasons. 

Nonetheless, by the tip of its seventh season, there have been rumors the present would not come again for an eighth season as a result of essential trio’s contracts being up. Finally, an eighth season was ordered…however with some main stipulations.

Necessary price range cuts noticed the exit of Dorian Gregory (who performed Darryl Morris), and the demotion of Brian Krause, who performed fan-favorite Leo Wyatt, Piper’s husband. “We could not afford to have him in all 22 episodes,” Kern informed TVLine, “so Brian’s character was frozen in Episode 10. The leap of religion for me hoped past hope of speaking him into coming again for the sequence finale. He was beneath no obligation to do this. I used to be banking on the truth that he was actually an ideal man, loyal to the viewers, and he was.”

The community additionally wished contemporary new faces introduced in in the event that they in the end wished to proceed the present with out Combs, Milano and McGowan for a ninth season or to star in a derivative, so Kaley Cuoco (pre-Massive Bang Idea) was introduced in. Her character Billie was a novice witch who turned a psuedo-younger sister for the Halliwells…however she wasn’t precisely a favourite for followers or critics. 

Recent off of eight Easy Guidelines, this was Cuoco’s first expertise on an hour-long drama and admitted sitcoms have been “a lot simpler to grasp.” And in audio commentary for the DVD launch of season eight, she admitted to not being snug with a number of the costumes she was put in. 

When Charmed ended its run in 2006, it beat Laverne & Shirley because the longest-running sequence with feminine leads. However these feminine leads weren’t pleased with how the WB dealt with the present’s ending.

“They made a giant announcement that we have been canceled. I am like, How is it doable to cancel one thing that does not exist?… [Since] all three contracts are performed, there’s successfully no present,” McGowan stated. “So then why would you [announce a cancellation]?… Form of lame to dishonor one thing that is labored for them for therefore lengthy.”

Combs added, “The WB by no means handled us effectively, so we did not count on lots of farewell needs and flowers or playing cards.”

Now, over a decade after the unique Charmed ended its run, The CW’s reboot is ready to debut on Sunday, with Madeleine Mantock, Melonie Diaz, and Sarah Jeffery enjoying 2018’s Vera sisters. The brand new twist on the story comes from Jane the Virgin government producer Jennie Urman, with the pilot script written by Jessica O’Toole and Amy Rardin

Our OG witches? Lower than thrilled by the information of the reboot, which had been dangled like a carrot in entrance of followers’ faces for years earlier than lastly coming to fruition. 

Probably the most vocal of the unique Halliwell sisters was Combs, who took to Twitter instantly to specific her disappointment. 

“This is the factor. Till you ask us to rewrite it like Brad Kern did weekly do not even consider capitalizing on our arduous work,” she wrote on the time. “Charmed belongs to the four of us, our huge quantity of writers, crews and predominantly the followers. FYI you’ll not idiot them by proudly owning a title/stamp. So bye.”

And Combs particularly took situation with the truth that the brand new iteration of the beloved present was being described as a “fierce, humorous, feminist reboot of the unique sequence,” principally that last F-word: feminist.

Guess we forgot to do this the primary go round. Hmph,” she tweeted. She then adopted up with a message to individuals who did not perceive why she wasn’t supportive of the brand new present, which was going to be produced, written and starring all ladies. 

“Whereas some could not get why I take situation with the community that did not wish to renew Charmed 12 years in the past ‘reimagining’ it now let me simply say I perceive it completely,” she tweeted. “Additionally this kinda stuff given all that Rose and Alyssa have performed currently…um no. Simply No.”

Rose McGowan, Megyn Kelly

NBC Information’ Megyn Kelly TODAY

In fact, Combs is referencing her former co-stars involvement within the #MeToo motion ever since the New York Occasions and The New Yorker reported a long time’ price of sexual misconduct and assault allegations by Harvey Weinstein in October 2017. Milano was even one of many first actors to assist revive Tarana Burke‘s decade-old #MeToo motion with a tweet, whereas McGowan was one of many first to talk out towards Weinstein, collaborating within the New York Occasions exposé.

However McGowan criticized Milano after she publicly voiced assist for Georgina Chapman, Weinstein’s estranged spouse, saying she was “an excellent girl” throughout an interview on Megyn Kelly As we speak

“You make me wish to vomit. You really gave me a physique flashback. Effectively performed, pretend one – Individuals,” McGowan tweeted about her former on-screen sister, together with a hyperlink to an article citing Milano’s remarks.

Whereas selling her E! present Citizen Rose, McGowan revealed she joined Charmed again in 2001 for a really particular cause: to take care of visibility following her alleged assault by Weinstein, which McGowan stated occurred in 1997.

“I did the TV present so I may achieve a foothold internationally in all areas,” she defined, “so when the information broke I may have a foothold and other people would concentrate in each area throughout the globeThis can be a lengthy plan.”

McGowan hasn’t actually weighed in on the reboot, although she expressed contempt for a 2013 try and revive the present, merely saying, “Lame lame lame lamertons.”

Although Doherty took situation with the “offensive” insinuation that the unique model was not feminist, she tweeted, “I like Charmed. I additionally need it to be revered. I am merely selecting to be constructive about it as a result of negativity has no place in my life.” 

For Milano, she was damage not one of the unique forged or artistic workforce was initially contacted or requested to be included in anyway, however informed Parade, “I really feel prefer it’s both going to succeed or not, and if it succeeds once more, a complete new technology might be uncovered to the great thing about what Charmed was in a position to be for individuals, and if it does not succeed, then we do not have to listen to about it anymore.”

The reboot’s government producer Jennie Urman informed reporters that she may “empathize” with the unique forged’s emotions, particularly Combs’, saying, “It was an enormous a part of her life and if [she’s] watching it go in a special course, then after all that is going to be arduous. I perceive that.”

However they famous the reboot is a brand new story and new tackle the Halliwell sisters, not a remake, saying they “did not wish to mess with that mythology, clearly, as a result of it was eight years.”

On Oct. 7, Charmed celebrated its 20th anniversary, with a number of the Halliwell witches taking a second on social media to acknowledge the milestone.

“To all of the followers—there is no such thing as a one such as you. Thanks for loving the present we liked a lot,” Milano tweeted. “And thanks for listening, sharing, and rising with me. I recognize you.” 

Ever the center sister, Combs used fan-art to acknowledge the entire ladies who helped create Charmed’s enduring legacy—drama and all.

Do not miss E! Information each weeknight at 7 p.m., solely on E!